
Summary
Bullied by his matriarchal mother, abused by his siblings, ignored by his father, Poil de Carotte's childhood is as miserable as it could be. An illegitimate child, he is the main reason for the enmity which exists between his parents, who continue to live together just to keep up appearances. In the end, Poil de Carotte's suffering becomes more than he can bear...
Review
Drawing heavily on the poignant novel by Jules Renard on which it is based, Poil de carotte is a modest yet appealing film which has stood the test of time mainly because of the quality of its acting performances and its inherent humanity. It is more memorable than Julien Duvivier's earlier silent version of 1925, also named Poil de Carotte.
The part of Poil de Carotte was played by 11 year old Robert Lynen, who was alleged to have been discovered whilst walking down the Champs-Elysées in Paris. Lynen is totally captivating and the film made him an instant star, launching what looked like becoming a very promising film career – until he was shot dead whilst fighting against the Germans in 1944. Harry Baur, a legendary stage and film actor (who also died during World War II, allegedly at the hands of the Gestapo), also turns in a typically fine performance. The reconciliation between father and son at the end of the film provides its most enduring image, enough to melt the heart of all but the most stoical of spectators.
精神分析&电影。看完了泪流满面,说的不是我自己吗,呵呵
幽默富有生气动人的电影,虽然中间对推进情节的节奏有些慢,在情节上丰富有趣
经典+经典
3.5;无爱可诉的原声家庭对一个少年之成长的杀伤力有多强,孩子成为失爱父母互相憎恶的砝码,红发男孩虽被其母诟为“丑”,然而却是最善良的一个——和狗狗、和小女孩、和女仆的情谊多动人啊!也是唯一一个没有长歪的孩子,看看兄姐就知,他们已被这个家庭毁了。噩梦、游乐场的快速剪辑,争论有无偷窃的分屏,令人印象深刻。
[分屏+叠印]冗长、铺张;奇妙的是,Duvivier设定的家庭危机并非由于孩子显在的差异,而是因为性别的紧张的一致。双亲没分别,只不过“女”方男性得不够。Carotte失了本应“抛而复有”的识别,终至被全整的父再认领...这可是50s末的四百击都没触及的思虑啊。